Posts Tagged ‘MySpace’

.tel sucks? If there are good reasons why, I have yet to hear them.

Wednesday, August 5th, 2009

As time passes and the positive efforts concerning the .tel domain continue to progress, there remains a small group of people out there who feel compelled to repeat the same arguments concerning their negative views on .tel domains.

It would be nice if the anti .tel camp could come up with some new material, but it looks like they are running out of steam.

Although most of these arguments have been addressed in various locations online (forums, blogs, etc), here is a compilation of responses to the most commonly cited anti .tel rhetoric.

Q:
“.tel should have never been released”, “ICANN should be ashamed”

A:
Well they did. It’s here and it’s not going to go away. So either live with it or ignore it. I somehow doubt ICANN, Telnic, owners, prospects and others are worried about this minority view. All evidence points to .tel growing in popularity at this point.

Q:
“.tel is a hack”, “It’s in beta”, “It doesn’t work”, etc.

A:
Welcome to the Internet. .tel works and it works well for the task it needs to do. The same could have been (and has been) said for Windows, MANY software applications, web sites and even the Internet itself. If you don’t like what it does, no one is forcing you to care about it and like ANY technology, it’s only going to improve. This argument is, at best, a semi-sensationalist statement, but really holds no value and has been overstated.

Q:
“.tel would have been good in the 90s”

A:
I can not believe that this has actually been posted as part of the .tel debate, let alone that it is a recurring statement. Was anyone who says this ACTUALLY using computers in the 90s? In the 90s no one had their own web page, that was for geeks and corporations. Geocities pages, etc., were all run by geeks and porn pushers and NO ONE did online dating or had “profiles”. How many people had cell phones in the 90s or even computers? It is only in today’s World of personal profiles, ubiquitous richmedia, sophisticated handhelds and multimedia convergence that a dedicated contact hub has become useful. The anti .tel arguments put forth may have been valid in the 90s, but this is the 21st century where the Internet is comprised of more elements than just the Web and the Web is now about FAR more than web pages.

Q:
“.tel is targeted towards MySpace and FB users who will never buy it”

A:
In reality, .tel is intended for anyone who has more than one contact point, so pretty much everyone on Earth who is connected somehow. It just so happens that right now FB and MySpace are the big players. Lots of those people have social site profiles, but lots of the intended target market do not. Yes, .tel is marketing to MySpace and FB users, but who isn’t or wouldn’t if they could? People who use free sites do pay money and buy things, this is pretty much a fundamental element of online marketing, if they didn’t then why do FB and MySpace exist? It’s amazing how people make broad claims about things that are based solely on opinion without facts or even evidence.

Q:
“.tel domains are too restricted”, “When Telnic changes their policy, then maybe…”

A:
Too restricted to do what exactly? For the task is it assigned to do it is extremely robust and elegant. No, you can not point a .tel to a regular webserver but this is for many reasons that have been presented and are pretty easy to understand. So either you accept this, or you do not. If you do not like this aspect, then use something else. Thousands of people have accepted this fact and spent their money without complaint which would indicate that at least a few of them may see some value. Questioning whether this policy will change is completely pointless. Assume it will never happen and figure it out from there.

Q:
“You can do this on any TLD without restrictions”

A:
No you can not. NO other TLD uses the DNS for storage like .tel and no other will in this manner. Regardless of whether this is good or bad, it is an indisputable fact. This has many benefits that have been presented and no one has come up with a compelling reason why this is a “BAD” thing. .tel is fast and it’s lean, if you want extra frills, yes, please, go use something else.
The entire cost of ownership includes time, not just server and reg fees. Under MANY circumstances the time factor favors .tel when comparing apples to apples. And… Even if you could replicate the DNS storage system, why would you waste your time reinventing a wheel you can buy for $10.

Q:
“You can do the same for free on MySpace, FB, Google profiles, etc.”

A:
No you can not. ALL of those examples require you to set up an account with that organization and they own your URL. With .tel you own your .tel URL and it is not branded by being a sub-domain or directory of a domain. Your .tel is a simple, one-dot, no-slash URL. It is shocking how many people who are in the “domain business” and don’t grasp the necessity of URL ownership or would actually suggest that an account elsewhere is a comparable solution to owning your URL.

Q:
“You can’t develop them”

A:
Yes you can. Development FOR .tel is growing exponentially and this would be covered by the “.tel development” blanket. Populating a .tel directory is not much different from setting up a static web page so does this mean a large number of web page creators are also not web developers? How do databases fit into this terminology or Flash? Where exactly is the line that divides “developers” from the rest of the population? If I develop for .tel domains that I own, then I am developing my .tel domains. The anti .tel camp must be desparate for arguments if semantics and the meaning of the word “development” are a main point of contention.

Q:
“How do you plan to develop them?”

A:
The same way anyone else develops Internet applications. Using server-side programming, client-side apps and combining the two. Whatever you can’t do directly on a .tel, you can do on a related .tld or with other software. .tel domains are complimentary to other TLDs AND other communications technologies. It’s funny that so many .tel haters are also self-proclaimed “web developers” but ignore or can’t see this obvious basic concept.

Q:
“You can’t use PHP, AJAX, etc.”
Not hosted on the .tel itself, no you can’t and this is a well known fact covered everywhere in the most basic of materials about .tel.
You most certainly can use these technologies elsewhere to interact with .tel domains however. It is actually possible to update a .tel domain and NEVER use the Web. That is correct NO WEB. People use software and interact with the Internet without access to the WEB. This argument is a strong indicator of a narrow view of the Internet in general. I will repeat: .tel is for MORE than WEB pages and it is not dependent on WEB pages to work. The “WEB” is not the same as the “Internet”.

Q:
“You can’t monetize them”

A:
The blanket claim that .tel domains can not be monetized is founded by arrogance and/or a blatant disregard of the obvious. They are as viable as any other technology property out there. It goes without saying that to monetize anything online you need traffic and content. If someone is trying to build a .tel based business without complimentary technology and/or marketing ability, then yes they are foolish, but that has nothing to do with .tel and is the same for ANY product or service. To broadly and definitively state that ANYTHING (.tel or otherwise) can NOT be monetized is absurd.

Opinions presented by .tel haters are comprised of the same, repetitive opinions that have been listed above. If anyone has some new data or compelling info, feel free to let me know and I’d be happy to hear them, otherwise I think that about covers it.

There may be no new arguments on the side against .tel, but the arguments in favor of it’s success continue to grow.

See ya in the SERPs… Or more like, you’ll see me! ;)
FS

Dot-Tel Articles for Telsters

Tuesday, April 7th, 2009

Will .Tel take off?

Telnic Launches Multilingual Website

Telnic To Offer .Tel Domains Through Myspace

iWelt to Sell .tel

Is the new “.tel” domain more than just a pretty face on top of DNS?

Enjoy :D

R.I.P. Dot Com. We barely Knew Ye!

Tuesday, March 24th, 2009

by Scott Smith (Published with permission at telsters.com)

The late 90’s ushered in one of the most prominent “they were the best of times, they were the worst of times” eras the world has seen. The widespread acceptance of the then infant Internet as a creditable place to do business underpinned a modern day gold rush of epic proportions. Millions of new “surfers” went online and quickly became intoxicated by the ease at which they could communicate and buy and sell goods and services online. The true Internet boom had begun. Billions of dollars of profits were generated, seemingly out of thin air, as entrepreneurs exploited the power bestowed on them by fat cat venture capitalists and few well-chosen letters to the left of the dot in “dot com”. The Internet went mainstream and the dot com TLD extension was quickly established as the 800 lb. gorilla with domain names often changing hands for multi-millions of dollars.

But as is often the case, in a relative heartbeat, in March of 2000, the boom … bust. The bubble burst.

Poof.

Since then, with lessons learned, the rebuilding began. Over the last nine years generations of people have ingrained the progeny of the Internet into the fabric of their daily lives. One would be hard pressed to find someone who has never heard of, or are members one or more of MySpace, Facebook, Twitter, Linked In and hundreds of other social networks. Add to that all of the associated tubes, mash-ups, wikis, rss feeds, IMs, iTunes, text messages, tweets, blogs, pokes, flickrs, smileys, screen names, passwords, phone numbers and the like, it’s no wonder we’re submerged (or sinking) in a dysfunctional communications funk. We’re in a virtual communications Armageddon.

Surely there is a way to simplify this whole communications mess?

Enter the dot com killer. Welcome simplicity. Welcome Dot-tel.

Dot-tel (.tel) is the new kid on the block, the new ICANN approved TLD that will revolutionize the way we communicate. .tel will push the boundaries of communications and the internet to the next level, putting the power back into the hands of the individual when it comes to using and sharing contact information.

.tel domains enable you to store contact information, keywords and location
information and to publish it to the internet quickly and securely without having to build a website.

Henri Asseily CTO and Chief Strategist at Telnic, the. tel registry, is widely quoted today saying,

“This fundamental change in the use of the internet will break open the ability for anyone to now own a domain and be found from any device. This is the biggest innovation to hit the internet and communications and it seems fitting that we have achieved this on the 133rd anniversary of the first use of the telephone. From today, people will be able to dial a .tel name to connect with people. The future of communications is now wide open to innovation.”

Skeptics may chime in saying that – “What do you expect from a Telnic exec, surely they have to sing the praises of their new product. They need to push a ton of domains to recoup their multi-year, multi-million dollar investment”

That may be so. But here are only a few reasons why I think that .tel will be a smashing success:

.tel domains are unique: .tel is the only TLD extension designed from the ground up link directly to contact information stored in the DNS

.tel domains save money: .tel domains do not require websites to be built and hosted and aside from annual renewals, there are no fees for ongoing maintenance and development

.tel domains are easy to use: a .tel domain can be populated within minutes with all types of contact information, including the use of premium rate telephone numbers, payment via SMS premium rate short codes for content downloads and links to e-commerce sites ranging from third-party hosted auction pages through to fully-fledged e-commerce shops

.tel domains will be difficult to cybersquat: .tel domains can only be registered by registrants who provide at least one piece of verifiable contact information. Violators can quickly be identified and actions undertaken by the appropriate authorities

.tel domains have already been purchased by the big players: The New York City Police, American Idol, the X Factor, Britain’s Got Talent, Australian Idol, Pop Idol, Star Academy, BBC, BSkyB, Virgin Media, ITV, Fox, CBS, Discovery, HBO, MTV, Canal+, the Movie Channel, Yellow Pages and thousands of major corporations from around the world.

I could go with many more examples but let me share perhaps the single biggest reason why I think .tel will, over time, leave all other domain extensions floundering in its wake.

I have been a professional domainer for nearly 10 years. I have witnessed and/or actively participated in all of the new domain releases dating back to the 2002 .US landrush (which NeuStar thoroughly cocked up), up to and including .biz, .info, .eu, .asia, .name, .asia, .me and dozens of others.

In all of my years of domaining I have never seen a registry so proactively reach out and engage their audience like Telnic has. Having taken a page from the respective books that made the MySpace’s and the Facebook’s of the world so wildly popular, Telnic is embracing the community, joining the blogs and forums, asking people for their input and feedback and actually following up on promises to make the changes that will make .tel more user-friendly and ultimately more valuable for everyone. Senior executives actually return phone calls and emails, often within minutes of being sent.

Let me repeat – they follow up. Man is that refreshing! These guys make many of the executives at some of the other registries (NeuStar, listen to your colleagues!), look like buffoons.

I’ll finish with this anecdote. The aforementioned Henri Asseily, CTO of Telnic weighed in on a thread posted at www.telsters.com, the leading .tel forum, thusly. Henri answered the technical question posed and ended with this comment:

“Maybe once the community starts growing a bit we should have a simple poll.”

What a concept! Let’s ask the community what they want and see if we can make it work. Pure genius.

OK, so after this next proclamation, it’s highly likely that my fellow domainers will take up a collection to have the men in the white coats come and drag me off to the loony bin. But here goes…

I predict that within 4-6 years the .com TLD will be usurped from it’s lofty perch and be forever supplanted by .tel or one of its innovative contemporary TLDs.

Scott Smith is a professional domainer and President of TelCartel (www.telcartel.com), a registered reseller of domains which specializes in the distribution and promotion of .tel domains.

Telnic is the registry for .tel ( www.telnic.com).



All Dot-Tel Domain - Dot-Tel Articles - Dot-Tel Resources - Dot-Tel Registrars - Dot-Tel Discussion Forum - Dot-Tel Info - Dot-Tel Glitter - Dot-Tel for Adults